Aristotle and the Stoics  
Author(s): F. H. Sandback
Published by Cambridge Philological Society
Publication Date:  Available in all formats
ISBN: 9781913701161
Pages: 0

EBOOK (EPUB)

ISBN: 9781913701161 Price: INR 1695.99
Add to cart Buy Now
This study maintains that the extent of influence exerted by Aristotle on the Stoics has often been exaggerated by modern scholars. A collection of all references to him by authors other than Peripatetics, whether contemporary or belonging to the following century, shows that his importance as a philosopher was not then recognised and reveals a lack of evidence that his school-works were known. Professor Sandbach argues that it is a mistake to proceed on the assumption that the Stoics must have known his work, or even an outline of it, and been stimulated, whether to agreement or to modification. If the supposed evidence for Aristotelian influence is examined without this presumption, much is found to be flimsy and some can be confidently rejected. A residue remains of varying degrees of probability, which it is hard to estimate owing to our insufficient information, particularly about Zeno, about the Academy of his time, about Aristotle's exoteric works, and about memory of him in oral traditions.
Rating
Description
This study maintains that the extent of influence exerted by Aristotle on the Stoics has often been exaggerated by modern scholars. A collection of all references to him by authors other than Peripatetics, whether contemporary or belonging to the following century, shows that his importance as a philosopher was not then recognised and reveals a lack of evidence that his school-works were known. Professor Sandbach argues that it is a mistake to proceed on the assumption that the Stoics must have known his work, or even an outline of it, and been stimulated, whether to agreement or to modification. If the supposed evidence for Aristotelian influence is examined without this presumption, much is found to be flimsy and some can be confidently rejected. A residue remains of varying degrees of probability, which it is hard to estimate owing to our insufficient information, particularly about Zeno, about the Academy of his time, about Aristotle's exoteric works, and about memory of him in oral traditions.
Table of contents
  • Cover
  • Title Page
  • Copyright
  • Contents
  • Preface
  • Abbreviations
  • List of works cited
  • Chapter I: Introduction
  • Chapter II: References to Aristotle
  • Chapter III: Methods of Estimating Influence
  • Chapter IV: Logic
  • Chapter V: Ethics
  • Chapter VI: Physics
  • Chapter VII: Disregard of Peculiarly Aristotelian Ideas
  • Chapter VIII: Conclusion
  • Panaetius and Posidonius
  • Appendix: Ocellus Lucanus
  • Notes
  • Index
  • Back Cover
User Reviews
Rating